Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

1878 Island 1040
Baxter Muskoka P0E 1E0

$799,000
Residential Freehold beds: 3 baths: 2.0

Main Photo: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 1: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 2: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 3: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 4: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 5: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 6: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 7: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 8: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 9: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 10: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 11: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 12: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 13: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 14: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 15: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 16: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 17: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 18: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 19: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 20: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 21: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 22: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 23: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 24: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 25: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 26: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 27: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 28: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Photo 29: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
X12351582
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
2
In about 1.5 hours from the GTA, you can be in Honey Harbour and then it's a 5 minute straight shot from the nearest marinas to this property by boat. The 1400 square foot cottage features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and a bright and open living / dining / kitchen area. Lover's Bay is a quiet inlet off the main channel where there is virtually no boat traffic even though it's so close to the inner harbour. The cottage is perched atop a vast granite hill and was designed to take advantage of the natural light and expansive views. There is excellent deep water at the dock for diving and swimming and if you are a watersports enthusiast, there are great locations for that in the immediate vicinity. Georgian Bay offers unlimited boating so you can take a day trip over to the town of Midland or, if you're looking for a longer boat ride, you could head up to Henry's or Parry Sound. If you want to use your cottage in the winter, this one is fully winterized and can be accessed by snowmobile or even on foot in the winter once the ice is safe. There are even services to get you there and back by scoot or hovercraft in the winter and water taxis in the summer.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Detached
Home Style:
1 Storey/Apt
Total Approx Floor Area:
1500-2000
Lot Size:
.50-1.99
Depth:
395'
Frontage:
155'
Topography:
Rocky, Sloping, Wooded/Treed, Hilly
Direction Faces:
East
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
2.0
Water supply:
Other
Kitchens:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
3
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
9
Zoning:
SRI1
Heating type:
Baseboard
Heating Fuel:
Electric
Foundation:
Piers
Roof:
Metal
Basement:
None
Fireplace/Stove:
No
Alternative Power:
None
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Parking Features:
None
Parking Spaces:
0
Total Parking Spaces:
0.0
Rural services:
Cell Services, Electricity Connected, Internet High Speed
Family Room:
No
Possession Details:
Flexible
Pool:
None
Link:
No
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Included In
Assessment:
$389,000
Assessment Year:
2024
Taxes:
$3,210 / 2024
Assessment:
$389,000.00 / 2024
Georgian Bay
Baxter
Muskoka
Island, Marina, Wooded/Treed, Waterfront
Primary Bedroom - Main Floor
Deck
Unknown
Metal/Steel Siding
154'
Island, Dock, Winterized
Direct
Deep, Clean
None
South East
Direct
By Water, Water Only
Georgian Bay
Bay
Heated Waterline, UV System, Water Treatment
Not Applicable
Private
Floor
Type
Size
Other
Ground
Living Room
24'7" × 11'1"
Ground
Kitchen
24'7" × 11'1"
Combined w/Dining
Ground
Pantry
9'11" × 3'7"
Ground
Utility Room
11'7" × 5'9"
Ground
Bedroom
11'9" × 8'4"
Ground
Bedroom
11'9" × 8'4"
Ground
Bedroom
11'8" × 10'10"
Floor
Ensuite
Pieces
Other
Ground
No
3
9'11" x 7'11" 3 Pc Bath
Ground
Yes
2
6'11½" x 3'3" 2 Pc Ensuite
Utilities Hydro:
Yes
Water Supply Types:
Lake/River, Water System
Special Designation:
Unknown
Sewers:
Septic
Air Conditioning:
None
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Ensuite Laundry:
No
Laundry Level:
Main Level
Date Listed:
Aug 19, 2025
Original Price:
Previous Price:
  • Photo 1: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 1 of 29
  • Photo 2: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 2 of 29
  • Photo 3: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 3 of 29
  • Photo 4: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 4 of 29
  • Photo 5: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 5 of 29
  • Photo 6: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 6 of 29
  • Photo 7: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 7 of 29
  • Photo 8: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 8 of 29
  • Photo 9: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 9 of 29
  • Photo 10: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 10 of 29
  • Photo 11: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 11 of 29
  • Photo 12: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 12 of 29
  • Photo 13: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 13 of 29
  • Photo 14: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 14 of 29
  • Photo 15: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 15 of 29
  • Photo 16: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 16 of 29
  • Photo 17: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 17 of 29
  • Photo 18: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 18 of 29
  • Photo 19: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 19 of 29
  • Photo 20: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 20 of 29
  • Photo 21: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 21 of 29
  • Photo 22: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 22 of 29
  • Photo 23: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 23 of 29
  • Photo 24: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 24 of 29
  • Photo 25: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 25 of 29
  • Photo 26: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 26 of 29
  • Photo 27: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 27 of 29
  • Photo 28: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 28 of 29
  • Photo 29: 1878 Island 1040 in Muskoka: Baxter House for sale (Georgian Bay)  : MLS®# X12351582
    Photo 29 of 29
Listed by Royal LePage In Touch Realty
Data was last updated August 23, 2025 at 07:15 PM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
90
Avg list price:
$940,000
Min list price:
$425,000
Max list price:
$4,895,000
Avg days on market:
72
Min days on market:
1
Max days on market:
547
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in Baxter. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
This website may only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered via the website. The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of the PropTx MLS®. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate.